Combining aerial imagery and field data estimates timber harvest and carbon emissions

first_imgArticle published by Sue Palminteri Researchers used images from LiDAR, a remote sensing technique that produces 3-D depictions of forest structure, to map logging areas—including roads, skid trails, gaps under the canopy, and decks used to store timber—for four timber concessions in Kalimantan on the island of Borneo.Pairing the LiDAR data with statistics on the number of trees felled and damaged, the researchers established equations relating the logging area data to both the volume of timber harvested and the resulting greenhouse gas emissions.The equations explained up to 87 percent of the variation in the volume of timber extracted.Using this method, governments, NGOs, and private organizations can verify timber harvests, formulate future management plans, and estimate harvest volumes and greenhouse gas emissions in other tropical forests, including areas of illegal logging. Selective logging—where specific high-value trees are cut—in tropical forests affects biodiversity, forest structure, and carbon storage. According to a 2009 study, timber was removed from over 20 percent of the area of humid tropical forests during the 2000s. Notably, more than half of the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from forest degradation in the tropics have come from selective timber harvests.Forest laws determine the areas, volumes, and maximum and minimum diameters of trees that can be extracted from a concession in any given year. Unlike forest clearing, selective logging is not easily quantified using satellite imagery.Most previous logging estimates rely on data from governments and timber companies, which are not independent and do not include illegal logging, for which there are few reliable, globally consistent assessments. Research suggests that illegal logging accounts for roughly 40 percent of all logging in the tropics, with figures as high as 72 percent for the Amazon.Illegally logged rainforest tree in Gunung Palung National Park in Indonesia. Image by Rhett A. Butler/MongabayNow, a pair of studies present a method using models to detect selective logging areas and estimate volumes of timber harvested, both legal and illegal, along with the resulting GHG emissions, from high-resolution aerial images. Relating forest structure from the images with timber harvest volumes and GHG emissions, the researchers state, enables future studies to deduce harvest volumes elsewhere from remote sensing alone.“Those wanting to know greenhouse gas emissions finally have an independent means to examine the impact of timber harvesting,” said Timothy Pearson, director of Arkansas-based non-profit Winrock International’s Ecosystem Services, and lead author of the study.Peering under the canopy through LiDARTraditional moderate-resolution (30-meter) satellite imagery can be ineffective at detecting a group of trees plucked out from the dense forest canopy by poachers. Resolutions greater than 1 meter can capture primary logging roads, the researchers state in their paper, but not skid trails created beneath the canopy by dragging logs or gaps exposed in the canopy by felled logs. Even high-resolution (1m) satellite images cannot peer through the canopy, where most of the damage from selective logging occurs.So how can we independently determine how much selective logging has occurred?Researchers have turned to aerial surveys that use LiDAR (Light Detection And Ranging), a remote sensing method that measures the return time of many thousands of pulsed laser beams sent to Earth’s surface from an aircraft. The return time of each pulse represents its distance from the airborne sensor. Some pulses penetrate the canopy, enabling scientists to generate high-resolution (sub-1 meter) three-dimensional images from the ground to top of the canopy and detect changes inside the forest.A pair of LIDAR images compare the structure of old-growth forest (right) to that of a new plantation of trees (left). Image by Sarah Frey, Oregon State University, CC 2.0.“What LiDAR allows us to do is not just see the canopy but also look underneath so we can see pockets and tunnels that are caused by the timber extraction,” said Pearson and co-author Stephen Hagen, a senior scientist at Applied GeoSolutions.Looking beneath the forest canopy is “really important for logging because when you are just removing a few trees you sometimes cause minimal damage to the canopy,” Pearson and Hagen said.For example, gaps created above the stump of a felled tree may be smaller than the tree’s crown, and branches from surrounding trees will partially cover where the felled tree stood.With LiDAR, we “don’t have to rely on being granted access to areas by companies or governments,” stressed Hagen.Pairing of LiDAR data with field data to estimate harvest volumes and emissionsA team of researchers, including Pearson and Hagen, recently developed automated algorithms based on commercial LiDAR data from Kalimantan, the Indonesian portion of Borneo, that can detect and generate fine-scale 3D maps of logging roads, skid trails, gaps, and decks used to store the logs.The four concessions used in this study, located in the Indonesian portion of the island of Borneo. Figure 1 of Pearson et al. 2018, Remote assessment of extracted volumes and greenhouse gases from tropical timber harvest, Environ Res Lett., 13, 065010. DOI: 10.1088/1748-9326/aac1fa licensed under CC BY 3.0.For the current study, funded by NASA’s Carbon Monitoring System, the team paired these maps with ground data on 188 trees cut from two logging concessions, Roda Mas and Timberdana.By pairing the LiDAR data with the known extracted timber, the researchers gleaned relationships between the roads, skid trails, and gaps and the volumes of timber extracted and formulated equations to estimate harvest volumes elsewhere based solely on remotely sensed LiDAR data.In addition, the team linked the volumes extracted with emissions factors to calculate the resulting GHG emissions. These factors included emissions arising from the 963 trees damaged incidentally (i.e. snapped or uprooted) during felling, storage, and extraction of the timber.On the left side is a high-resolution aerial photo of a portion of the Timberdana concession. The image on the right shows the same area with roads/decks in orange, skid trails in red, and canopy gaps in blue obtained by analyzing the LiDAR data. Images courtesy of Stephen Hagen.Relating forest structure to timber extractionThey developed three equations to estimate the volume of timber harvests and GHG emissions from the LiDAR data under different scenarios. The first equation, includes roads, gaps, and skid trails as predictors, and explained 87 percent of the variation in volume of timber extracted. According to Pearson, “that is a very strong relationship for an equation to have that much predictive power.”Damage caused by logging generated greater emissions in both concessions than either log extraction or infrastructure. Because the emissions factors were similar in both concessions, they combined them to allow for extrapolation to other concessions.When the researchers used the equation to calculate the volumes of timber extracted from the two surveyed concessions, Roda Mas and Timberdana, their estimates (59,452m3) were similar to the actual reported volumes (60,827m3).Next, they applied the equation to two other concessions for which LiDAR data were available but ground data were not. Sari Bumi Kasuma emerged with the highest carbon dioxide emissions, while Roda Mas came second. But per hectare, Timberdana had the highest rate of emissions, followed by Roda Mas.Estimated greenhouse gas emissions, in tons of carbon dioxide equivalents (t CO2e), associated with timber extraction in the four concessions due to logging infrastructure, incidental damage, and extraction. The error bars represent the 95% confidence interval of the total emissions of the concession. Figure 2 of Pearson et al. 2018, licensed under CC BY 3.0.A second equation was developed to estimate the volume of illegal logging where rivers, instead of roads, are used to extract timber. As a result, roads data were omitted from the equation, which still explained 86 percent of the variation in the timber harvest data.But what happens when both on-the-ground data and LiDAR are unavailable? Since LiDAR data are costly to obtain, the team created a third equation that considered only road length, which they found could predict 78 percent of the variation in the timber volume. Road lengths can be obtained from freely-available moderate resolution imagery.There is a linear relationship between the length of roads and the volume of timber extracted, the study found. Longer roads in an area are associated with more timber extracted. Figure 4 of Pearson et al. 2018, licensed under CC BY 3.0.The case of illegal logging Pearson explained that there are two types of illegal logging. The first occurs within legal concessions when “timber is extracted outside the area of the granted concession or goes beyond the maximum area that can be harvested in a given year or too many trees are extracted from the allowed area.” All three equations can be used for this case, he said, “but if only moderate resolution satellite data are available, the road equation could be used.”In the second type of illegal logging scenario, operators extract high-value trees from pristine or protected forests. “In this case,” Pearson said, “it would be very rare for roads to be built.” Instead, these logs are extracted by floating them out on rivers. Consequently, the second equation, based on only gap areas and skid trails, would be suitable to estimate the volume of extraction.Using the airborne LiDAR maps, the team identified an illegal logging site in Central Kalimantan, located outside of the concessions, which lacked roads and consisted only of skid trails and logging gaps. By applying the second equation, they estimated 730m3 of timber harvested (20 m3 per hectare) resulting in emissions of 45 tons of carbon dioxide equivalents per hectare, roughly half of the average rate of emissions of the legal concessions. They believe that relatively smaller trees harvested might explain the lower volumes and emissions.Using the approach to estimate logging in other areas The method can be applied to other upland forests in Kalimantan, whereas swamp forests have a different structure, leading to different relationships, said Pearson and Hagen.Application to tropical forests elsewhere will require both LiDAR and field data to create relationships. “It will be interesting going forward to examine how much the relationships vary in different forests and if there are patterns that will allow us to predict relationships for forests we haven’t visited,” they added.“We know for example that the Indonesia sites use bulldozers to skid the logs out of the forest, while many other logging operations use skidders, which have a smaller footprint,” Pearson noted.LiDAR image of an illegal logging site in Central Kalimantan, Indonesia showing skid trails in green and logging gaps in blue. These damaged areas are very difficult to detect with satellite imagery. Figure 5 of Pearson et al. 2018, licensed under CC BY 3.0.The researchers suggested that governments can use the approach to independently monitor concessionaires’ adherence to harvesting plans and apply appropriate taxes. Buyers, investors, and non-governmental organizations can use the approach to independently verify harvests to guide future management actions. Emissions data on timber harvests could inform countries’ commitments to international climate change and REDD+ programs.Limitations of the method One of the main downsides of the method is the high cost of obtaining LiDAR data, which usually limits data collection to a single set of overflights, said Michael Palace, associate professor at the University of New Hampshire, who was involved in the earlier automated algorithms study. Moreover, flying may be restricted in some areas.Apart from obtaining LiDAR images, there is the cost of collecting field data that links the forest structure variables to timber volumes and emissions, explained Pearson. However, he said, “the cost of collecting data in the field on an ongoing basis (let alone the issues of access) will make a remote method cost-effective, and where application is broad, this potentially would even cover the initial development costs.”“Ultimately, relationships could be created for all relevant regions, at which point the new imagery would be all that is needed,” he envisioned.Estimating timber volumes and emissions in areas without LiDAR flight data still requires field sampling, which can be even more costly than LiDAR over the long term. If timber harvest volumes can be estimated using remote sensing and equations, which can be done in hours, versus days, it can save time and money. Remote sensing can cover any area of land, eliminating the need for permission to visit a site and measure wood of logged trees, thereby offering a way to monitor illegal logging.Like other methods, estimation with LiDAR data paired with equations derived from ground data also has uncertainties, Pearson and Hagen said, but for purposes of an approximate estimation, it gives an “immediate value where none currently exist.”Citations Melendy, L. et al (2018). Automated method for measuring the extent of selective logging damage with airborne LiDAR data. Int. Soc. Photogra. Remote Sens, 139, 228–40., T.R.H., Bernal, B., Hagen, S.C., Walker, S.M., Melendy, L.K., Delgado, G. (2018). Remote assessment of extracted volumes and greenhouse gases from tropical timber harvest. Environmental Research Letters, 13, 065010. Popular in the CommunitySponsoredSponsoredOrangutan found tortured and decapitated prompts Indonesia probeEMGIES17 Jan, 2018We will never know the full extent of what this poor Orangutan went through before he died, the same must be done to this evil perpetrator(s) they don’t deserve the air that they breathe this has truly upset me and I wonder for the future for these wonderful creatures. So called ‘Mankind’ has a lot to answer for we are the only ones ruining this world I prefer animals to humans any day of the week.What makes community ecotourism succeed? In Madagascar, location, location, locationScissors1dOther countries should also learn and try to incorporateWhy you should care about the current wave of mass extinctions (commentary)Processor1 DecAfter all, there is no infinite anything in the whole galaxy!Infinite stupidity, right here on earth.The wildlife trade threatens people and animals alike (commentary)Anchor3dUnfortunately I feel The Chinese have no compassion for any living animal. They are a cruel country that as we knowneatbeverything that moves and do not humanily kill these poor animals and insects. They have no health and safety on their markets and they then contract these diseases. Maybe its karma maybe they should look at the way they live and stop using animals for all there so called remedies. DisgustingConservationists welcome China’s wildlife trade banThobolo27 JanChina has consistently been the worlds worst, “ Face of Evil “ in regards our planets flora and fauna survival. In some ways, this is nature trying to fight back. This ban is great, but the rest of the world just cannot allow it to be temporary, because history has demonstrated that once this coronavirus passes, they will in all likelihood, simply revert to been the planets worst Ecco Terrorists. Let’s simply not allow this to happen! How and why they have been able to degrade this planets iconic species, rape the planets rivers, oceans and forests, with apparent impunity, is just mind boggling! Please no more.Probing rural poachers in Africa: Why do they poach?Carrot3dOne day I feel like animals will be more scarce, and I agree with one of my friends, they said that poaching will take over the world, but I also hope notUpset about Amazon fires last year? Focus on deforestation this year (commentary)Bullhorn4dLies and more leisSponsoredSponsoredCoke is again the biggest culprit behind plastic waste in the PhilippinesGrapes7 NovOnce again the article blames companies for the actions of individuals. It is individuals that buy these products, it is individuals that dispose of them improperly. If we want to change it, we have to change, not just create bad guys to blame.Brazilian response to Bolsonaro policies and Amazon fires growsCar4 SepThank you for this excellent report. I feel overwhelmed by the ecocidal intent of the Bolsonaro government in the name of ‘developing’ their ‘God-given’ resources.U.S. allocates first of $30M in grants for forest conservation in SumatraPlanet4dcarrot hella thick ;)Melting Arctic sea ice may be altering winds, weather at equator: studyleftylarry30 JanThe Arctic sea ice seems to be recovering this winter as per the last 10-12 years, good news.Malaysia has the world’s highest deforestation rate, reveals Google forest mapBone27 Sep, 2018Who you’re trying to fool with selective data revelation?You can’t hide the truth if you show historical deforestation for all countries, especially in Europe from 1800s to this day. WorldBank has a good wholesome data on this.Mass tree planting along India’s Cauvery River has scientists worriedSurendra Nekkanti23 JanHi Mongabay. Good effort trying to be objective in this article. I would like to give a constructive feedback which could help in clearing things up.1. It is mentioned that planting trees in village common lands will have negative affects socially and ecologically. There is no need to even have to agree or disagree with it, because, you also mentioned the fact that Cauvery Calling aims to plant trees only in the private lands of the farmers. So, plantation in the common lands doesn’t come into the picture.2.I don’t see that the ecologists are totally against this project, but just they they have some concerns, mainly in terms of what species of trees will be planted. And because there was no direct communication between the ecologists and Isha Foundation, it was not possible for them to address the concerns. As you seem to have spoken with an Isha spokesperson, if you could connect the concerned parties, it would be great, because I see that the ecologists are genuinely interested in making sure things are done the right way.May we all come together and make things happen.Rare Amazon bush dogs caught on camera in BoliviaCarrot1 Feba very good iniciative to be fallowed by the ranchers all overSponsoredcenter_img Forests, LiDAR, Mapping, Monitoring, Remote Sensing, Technology, Wildtech last_img read more

And You Thought the Tech Blog Echo Chamber was Bad

first_imgTags:#New Media#web josh catone 1 Related Posts Top Reasons to Go With Managed WordPress Hosting A Web Developer’s New Best Friend is the AI Wai…center_img You see it happen every day: a story breaks on Techmeme, and 30 minutes later, the headline is followed up by tens of “discussion links.” Some bloggers weigh in just to get the trackback link, or the link on Techmeme, some because they’re generally interested in the news, and some because they think they have something new to add to the conversation. Whatever the reason, though, the effect is the same — the tech blogosphere becomes an echo chamber, and the more bloggers writing about a story, the more clout it has and the more chance it gets repeated by a mainstream news outlet. In all, though, the effects are mostly innocuous. In the political blogosphere, though, a repeated rumor can carry considerably more significant consequences.The Observer’s John Noughton relates a story of how unsubstantiated rumors have been making their way from political blogs and forums to the mainstream press, and in doing so makes a case for a future of media in which citizen journalism takes a backseat to good old fashioned reporting.Rumors Gone WildSpecifically, Noughton cites a rumor that Michelle Obama, wife of US presidential candidate Barack Obama, was caught on video tape hurling a racial epithet about white people. The rumor started on Larry Johnson’s No Quarter blog. His source? “Someone in touch with a senior Republican” who knows that a “major McCain backer has a copy of the tape.” Later, Johnson says he’s learned more about the tape via “five separate sources who have spoken directly with people who have seen the tape.”Despite the clear lack of a credible source, the rumor had serious legs. From friend of a friend of a friend hearsay, to a mention on Fox News as “credible buzz,” to Obama being asked about it by a reporter from the well-respectd McClatchy News Service. “So the story whirls around the echo-chamber of the paranoid, right-wing blogosphere, with the odd whisk from Fox News reporters, until it reaches hysteria,” says Noughton. And though no tape has surfaced, damage has potentially been done.Therein, perhaps, lies a danger in putting too much credence in the blogosphere and citizen journalism. At times having untrained eyes on the ground can be invaluable at getting the story reported, and sometimes citizen journos can beat the mainstream press to a breaking story. But when your sources are relying on rumors heard from friends, lending credence to those rumors by mentioning them in the mainstream press is toxic.We’ve seen rumors run wild on the tech end have real-world consequences as well. Last May when Engadget erroneously reported that Apple was planning to delay Leopard and the iPhone, the company lost $4 billion in market cap in an afternoon. Even though Engadget quickly updated its headline and story when Apple denied the rumors and said their source (a memo) was a fake, the story was frozen in time on Techmeme and in people’s RSS readers with the wrong information.The SolutionWith the rise of Twitter, mobile video blogging, and other tools of citizen journalism, the news cycle is now seconds. With news rolling in non-stop 24 hours per day, the continuous, Twitterized cycle doesn’t leave much time for fact checking — speed matters. But that’s not the future that Noughton hopes for.When rumors published and repeated without checking the facts can have far-reaching consequences — like influencing voters in a US presidential election, or knocking $4 billion off a company’s market cap — accuracy should count for something. Noughton provides a moral for the tale of the phantom Michelle Obama tape: “If confronted with online rumours, investigate first, report later.” 8 Best WordPress Hosting Solutions on the Market Why Tech Companies Need Simpler Terms of Servic…last_img read more

Sponsored Stories Now Appearing In The Facebook News Feed

first_imgFacebook is Becoming Less Personal and More Pro… alicia eler Related Posts Guide to Performing Bulk Email Verification “Sponsored Stories are regular stories that people may see in their News Feeds already, but that a marketer has paid to feature on Facebook,” a Facebook spokesperson tells us. “We’ve begun slowly rolling these out in News Feed and are labeling them as ‘featured.’ These stories respect your and your friends’ privacy settings, and people will only see stories about people and Pages they’ve already connected to.”The Facebook Help Center includes information about how businesses can use the “featured posts” option to bring more users to their Facebook Page. Featured stories that users might see in the news feed include new posts from the Facebook Page, when a friend likes something (either the Facebook Page itself or a post on that page), when a friend checks in, plays a game, or uses an app. Facebook ads in the right-rail are still called “sponsored,” at least for now. Yesterday Facebook began rolling out sponsored stories in the main news feed. At the end of 2011, when this announcement first broke, a Facebook spokesperson told us that these ads would be clearly marked “sponsored” so as not to confuse them with other stories. But it looks like – surprise! – Facebook changed its mind somewhere between the announcement and the rollout, and decided to call the ads “featured” instead of “sponsored.” This is confusing for the user but rather advantageous to the advertiser. center_img Tags:#advertising#Facebook#news#web Featured stories in the news feed may help ease the common “over-liking” problem of Facebook fan pages. Often times users will “like” tons of Facebook Pages, but rarely check them unless they happen to pop up in the news feed. If a Facebook user would prefer not to receive ads, they can “unlike” Facebook Pages, thus decreasing the number of “featured” stories that might appear in the news feed.Facebook users will certainly be pissed off about this change. But freemium comes with a price: Somewhat veiled adage for a user’s Internet-addicted eyeballs. And that’s something every Facebook user knows. The Dos and Don’ts of Brand Awareness Videos A Comprehensive Guide to a Content Auditlast_img read more

Position Vacant!

first_imgAre you looking for a thrilling career in the sports industry? Touch Football Australia (TFA) is seeking suitably qualified applicants for positions in our National office located in Canberra.Please click on the respective jobs below to open the Position Description.Graphic Design and Multimedia CoordinatorApplications close 5.00pm AEDT 4th November For further information or to lodge your application for these career opportunities, please email [email protected] LinksPosition Vacantlast_img read more

10 months agoArsenal escape FA charge for Alli bottle incident

first_imgArsenal escape FA charge for Alli bottle incidentby Freddie Taylor10 months agoSend to a friendShare the loveArsenal are unlikely to be punished by the FA after Dele Alli was struck with a water bottle thrown from the stands at the Emirates.The Gunners are scouring CCTV to try and identify the culprit.As it was an individual rather than a group, the FA will assist Arsenal in their investigation rather than punish them.Alli was struck after scoring Spurs’ second goal in their 2-0 win over Arsenal in the EFL Cup quarter-final. About the authorFreddie TaylorShare the loveHave your saylast_img read more

10 months agoRanieri driving Fulham bid for Besiktas defender Vida

first_imgTagsTransfersAbout the authorPaul VegasShare the loveHave your say Ranieri driving Fulham bid for Besiktas defender Vidaby Paul Vegas10 months agoSend to a friendShare the loveFulham boss Claudio Ranieri is reviving his plans for Besiktas defender Domagoj Vida.Le 10 Sport says Ranieri wants to boost his defensive options and is eager to bring Vida to London.The Italian has been tracking Vida since his time in charge of Leicester City.The Cottagers are ready to bid for the Croatia international, confident of landing Vida for a realistic fee.Besiktas, in the midst of financial difficulties, need to sell to balance the books this month. last_img read more

Comedian poised to take over presidency in Ukraine

first_imgKiev: Ukrainians went to polls Sunday in the second round of an extraordinary election with a comedian who plays a president on TV expected to win in a stunning rebuke to the political establishment. Forty-one-year-old Volodymyr Zelensky’s bid to lead the country of 45 million people was initially dismissed as a joke when he announced his candidacy on New Year’s Eve. But now all opinion polls suggest incumbent President Petro Poroshenko is heading for defeat amid widespread anger over poverty, corruption and war. Also Read – Saudi Crown Prince ‘snubbed’ Pak PM, recalled jet from USZelensky’s victory is expected to open a new chapter in the history of a country that has gone through two popular uprisings in two decades and is mired in a five-year conflict with separatists in the east. Polling stations opened at 0500 GMT as voters from Ukrainian-speaking regions in the west to Russian-speaking regions in the war-torn east went to cast their ballots. Speaking outside a polling booth in the capital Kiev, Galyna, 81, said she voted for Zelensky. Also Read – Record number of 35 candidates in fray for SL Presidential polls”Because I am against Poroshenko,” said the pensioner who refused to give her last name. Zelensky has tapped into widespread frustration over graft, poverty and a conflict with separatists that has claimed some 13,000 lives. But others doubted whether the consummate showman would be able to take on the country’s vested interests, negotiate with the likes of German Chancellor Angela Merkel and stand up to Russia’s Vladimir Putin. Viktoriya Olomutska in Kiev suggested many voted for teacher-turned-president Vasyl Goloborodko, Zelensky’s character in the popular TV show “Servant of the People”, now in its third season and available on Netflix. “People have gone mad,” said the 39-year-old Poroshenko supporter, adding many pinned their hopes on “a fictional character”. Seventy-eight-year-old Maria said it was incomprehensible to her that a majority supported Zelensky. “There cannot be so many fools in the country,” she fumed. “But no, apparently there are!” A survey by the Rating pollster this week showed Zelensky winning 73 per cent of the vote against 27 per cent for Poroshenko. Exit poll results are expected at 1700 GMT and the first preliminary results several hours later. The stakes are high for a country dependent on international aid and seen as a buffer between the European Union and Russia. Poroshenko, 53, has argued Zelensky is a political novice unfit to be a war-time commander-in-chief. On Saturday, Poroshenko made a last-ditch plea to voters, begging Ukrainians to think twice before backing his rival.last_img read more

Take appropriate action against Mukul HC directs RS Secretariat

first_imgNew Delhi: The Delhi High Court recently directed the Rajya Sabha Secretariat and the chairman of the Housing Committee for taking “appropriate action” against former Parliamentarians for illegally occupying government accommodation.It may be mentioned that an RTI was filed by Arindam Ghosh, an advocate, early this year for illegally occupying government accommodation by former Rajya Sabha MP and BJP leader Mukul Roy for one and half years and not paying rent for six months. Also Read – 2019 most peaceful festive season for J&K: Jitendra SinghRoy, who had resigned from the Upper House of the Parliament on October 11, 2017, requested the House Committee of Rajya Sabha for an extension for six months of stay at 181, South Avenue MP Flat, after one month’s concessional period ‘ at market rent’. On the respective dates of February 11, May 2 and June 26 last year, Roy wrote a letter to the House Committee for seeking a further one-year extension after the chairman decided to cancel his extension, but later it was granted. Also Read – Personal life needs to be respected: Cong on reports of Rahul’s visit abroadHowever, on that matter calling the procedure “illegal”, the court mentioned in its statement, “The rules clearly stipulate that members of Rajya Sabha can retain residential accommodation allotted to them only for a maximum period of one month after resignation/ retirement. The occupation of such accommodations is per se illegal. For that, the replies to the RTI applications reveal that the ex-MPs are being illegally allowed to occupy such government accommodations. Even if it is assumed that such an extension is permissible without regular payment of market rate rent for the period of their extended stay.” On the other side, according to a letter from the Director of Estates in February 2019, the Committee received the last rent in November 2018. However, the court also said that the market rate for Lok Sabha pool of accommodations was determined in 2005. As such the rates cannot be made applicable to MPs of Rajya Sabha. “Such market rates being more than a decade old, are unacceptable as they make a significant dent in the pockets of the public exchequer,” the court statement added. The court further assured of an appropriate course of actions would be initiated by the respondent authorities under the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupation) Act, 1971. Apart from Mukul Roy, names of former Rajya Sabha MPs Rangaswamy Ramakrishna, Rajni Patel and Thomas Sangma are also mentioned in the RTI.last_img read more

Mourinho slams Maguire over Colombia drama

first_imgManchester United boss Jose Mourinho has called out Harry Maguire’s behaviour in England’s meeting with Colombia at the World Cup, saying that he was  “surprised” by all that antics during the clash.Maguire was accused of diving after going down inside the box under minimal contact and was later in the same match caught giving signs for the referee to examine VAR when Wilmar Barrios headbutted Jordan Henderson.It appears Mourinho is not happy such actions of Maguire as he questions why only certain players, such as Brazil forward Neymar, are criticised in similar circumstances.“People are focusing on Neymar, but if it was only Neymar, I’d be happy, but it’s not only Neymar,” he told Russia Today via Metro Uk.harry maguire, manchester UnitedMaguire says United need to build on today’s win George Patchias – September 14, 2019 Harry Maguire wants his United teammates to build on the victory over Leicester City.During the summer, Harry Maguire was referred to as the ultimate…“Every team has lots of diving, lots of pretending, lots of putting pressure on the referee.“It’s not about England and Colombia, it’s almost every match. I was surprised to see central defenders like Harry Maguire, normally he is a very honest guy, diving in the attacking box, asking the referee for VAR.“The players should feel the responsibility of playing in the World Cup in front of billions of spectators.”The match at the Spartak Stadium was tough and suspense filled with none of the spectators knowing what could happen next as they finished 1-1 after extra time, but England prevailed 4-3 on penalties to knock out Colombia.last_img read more

AFA asks the press to leave Messi alone for a while

first_imgThe AFA president truly believes Lionel Messi will return to the Argentina National team, but he requested the local media to let him rest until next year.After the latest heartbreak that Argentina suffered in the last World Cup by getting eliminated against France in the round of 16, the local press feared that Lionel Messi would bid farewell to the national team and never play another tournament with the squad. But new statements from the AFA president have surfaced, in which he reveals he spoke with Lionel Messi and is convinced the player only needs to rest until next year so he can feel motivated once again.El titular de AFA sostuvo que no piensa “dar un paso al costado” por la actuación de Argentina en el Mundial. (Vía @BonelliOK)— Radio Mitre (@radiomitre) July 24, 2018David Villa, FC BarcelonaTop 10 players who played for both Barcelona and Valencia Boro Tanchev – September 14, 2019 Time to talk about the best players who represented both Barcelona and Valencia, prior to their La Liga encounter at Camp Nou this evening.“We will always trust Messi, we have to leave him be for a while and let him rest from the National Team. Let the man start his tournament in Spain and maybe next year… we will see what happens. I believe we have a very healthy back and forth relationship. I believe Leo deeply loves the Argentina National team but this last World Cup result was a hard blow for him, but Argentina really needs him,” said AFA president Claudio Tapia to Radio Mitre in Argentina.#AFA Tapia: “Yo creo que Messi va a seguir”:— TyC Sports (@TyCSports) July 24, 2018During 2019 we have a Copa America next summer in Brazil, the general idea for AFA is to sign a competent manager who can form a competitive enough squad that can practice for the better part of the year before the tournament, and then only add Messi to the new generation of players who will represent their country for the upcoming years. AFA’s intentions are to include a 34-year old Lionel Messi to the final list for the Qatar World Cup in 2022.last_img read more